Thought and Reason

No for the Have-nots ? (A parallel between Nuclear NPT and Tata Nano)

Stench-filled, crowded buses, dusty auto rickshaws, two-wheelers driving like Siamese twins in the overcrowded roads of India…if this makes you feel nostalgic (not to mention, nauseatic), then the new Tata Nano (the Rs. One-Lakh Car) appears to be the manna sought after, by the rising Indian bourgeois.

While hopeful masses have welcomed the idea with open arms, several others are sceptical about the Nano, which they say, will only add to the over-crowded roads of India, increase pollution and congestion, and clog the already choked road network.

This interestingly, is similar to nuclear non-proliferation – The five states that are already nuclear states (US, UK, China, Russia and France) are the ones that push the rest of the world to not develop/acquire nuclear weapons. They do not seem to disarm themselves, but want developing countries to stem their plans to go nuclear. Similarly, existing car-owners and the more affluent of society are the ones who are critical of the Nano being so accessible to the common man. The Haves continue to sit in the lap of luxury, while preaching abstinence to the Have-Nots !

Be it the nuclear NPT or reducing road pollution, it calls for a solution by everyone, especially the Haves, and not just the Have-nots.

Interestingly, we can thus draw a parallel between nuclear non-proliferation and the road congestion scenario in India:

1- NON-PROLIFERATION: Non-nuclear weapon states (NNWS) agree to not acquire/manufacture/seek assistance in acquiring nuclear weapons. Nuclear states agree to not use their nuclear energy towards making weapons, to not assist non-nuclear weapon states to acquire nuclear weapons, and to not use their nuclear weapons against NNWS except in response to an attack. Similarly, those individuals who already own vehicles (cars/motorbikes/etc.) must consciously abstain from using their private vehicles for daily commute. And those who do not own a vehicle must try to avoid acquiring/using one.

2- As the above may seem unfair to the common man who is waiting to taste luxury himself, we embark on adopting the second pillar of the NPT – DISARMAMENT. As nuclear states must disarm themselves of nuclear and other weapons, so also should individuals who possess private vehicles, disarm themselves of this luxury in their daily life. This is of course, on the premise that India has a world-class public transport system. People must use the public transport system for their daily commute, and restrict usage of private vehicles (cars/bikes) to the weekends. Importantly, commuters need to develop civic sense, not pull/push one another in a hurry to get into or out of the vehicle, and not use the vehicle as a dustbin for their unimaginable garbage.

3- PEACEFUL USE OF ENERGY: While the world must cruise towards using nuclear energy for peaceful purposes and not for weapons/distruction, the Indian government must also use resources to develop a robust, convenient and world-class Public transport system that is accessible to everyone in the country. Take the London Underground railway system for instance..with all its deficiencies, it is still the lifeline of the working class. Trains arrive on time, and they are indeed crowded during peak hours, but the network does not halt for trivial reasons. The Mumbai train system could be a good local example. Public transport vehicles (buses/trains) must be refurbished, made clean and safe to use, and the government must increase the number/frequency of buses, to cater to a wider working-population. And for heaven’s sake, they must be “p-u-n-c-t-u-a-l”.

Another action point by the Government, could be to introduce motoring taxation for privately owned vehicles plying on central roads of urban areas during peak hours, for example, by levying a congestion charge. This, with the dual objective of generating revenue and to stemming the usage of private vehicles, thereby minimising congestion.

To summarise, while the world drives towards peace, individuals like us must walk towards building a less-congested road network in India. I hope we all get to own Tata Nano(s) and still use MRTS in our daily life. Let’s hope that 2008 heralds personal disarmament and national progress.

3 replies on “No for the Have-nots ? (A parallel between Nuclear NPT and Tata Nano)”

Hi Pallavi

Manna sought by rising Indian burgeois?

Marxian intrepretation of society is discredited and thankfully confined to the dustbin of history
‘Burgeois’ is a mythical Marxian construct .We should desist from using that in Indian context

Nano is the People’ car in the truest sense of the term..I think it promises to be a truly liberating expereince for the Indian masses that has suffered from the tyranncy of ‘Stalinist’ Nehruvian Indian state that failed miserably to build public infrastructure.

Nano is the symbol of Indian resurgence.Exemplary India entreprenur who has delivered a outstanding piece of automobile operating under hostile environment

Hi Pallavi,

Your Blog does sound extremely concerned about the eco-system and improvement of Mass Rapid Transport System. But do you think India and Indians can rely on the time-lines as kept by the politicians to improve on the same? Having said so, I would also like to quote an example of Calcutta- More knows to be the “London of India”, where tube-rails exist by forms in the form of “Metro”, and actually is p-u-n-c-u-a-l, but that definitely does’nt solve the problem of overcrowdink streets.

I think this initiative from the TATA’s is definitely a boon for the Indian commuter, who cannot dream of “owning” a car. Think of the menace created by the bikers (like me!), the havoc created by the Auto fraternity…Dont you think the Nano makes sense??? 🙂


So, what do you think?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s